When was the last time an NFL team started 0-7 while having its purported franchise quarterback available in every game? Has it happened this millennium?
Of the 22 teams that started 0-7 or worse since 2000, only Derek Carr on the 2014 Oakland Raiders, DeShone Kizer on the 2017 Cleveland Browns and Jared Goff on the 2021 Detroit Lions started every game at quarterback. Most teams were beset by cursed diptychs or triptychs like Kerry Collins and Curtis Painter (2011 Colts) or Jon Kitna, Daunte Culpepper (!) and Dan Orlovsky (2008 Lions). Most franchise QBs on the list were fresh off the draft stage and entering a predictably terrible situation.
That Justin Herbert is enduring this miserable 0-7 start as the lone signal caller while also having several years of pretty good play under his belt is staggering.1 I’m intrigued to see how much longer this can go on, if only because it keeps Madison Beer’s name in the conversation as the scapegoat.2 Perhaps the Chargers will make it to 0-11 again? That’s how they started back in 2000. Ryan Leaf was their quarterback for the first three and a half games, but a wrist injury forced him out for the second half of Week 4. Who replaced him? None other than current Chargers’ coach Jim Harbaugh, who went on to lose five straight games as a starter.
- This is where the NFL’s lack of a reliable qualifier like “All-Star” is irritating. In the NBA, that term connotes a player who is clearly a well above average contributor while stopping short of All-NBA or MVP consideration. “Pro Bowler” carries no such weight. ↩︎
- Serious question: Would you accept professional humiliation and failure (but still a huge paycheck) in exchange for Mrs. Beer’s companionship? I would. ↩︎